The Student News Site of Walt Whitman High School

The Black & White

T-Mobile’s cellphone tower should be built on school grounds

By Stewart Longsworth

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.

Email This Story

2 total views, 1 views today

A proposed T-Mobile cellphone tower on school grounds has triggered plenty of controversy.  A group of parents and nearby residents vehemently opposed to a cell tower believes the emitted radio-frequency waves will cause cancer and other health problems over a long period of time.  T-Mobile has snapped back, defending their towers with studies and questioning the validity of contrary evidence.

While this debate over cell towers may be confusing, it is missing a simple truth: if we look around us, there are radio wave emissions everywhere, from gigantic radio towers to TV sets.  In the big scheme, one weak cell tower would be relatively harmless.

On the flip side, a cellphone tower would bring better service to the area and money to MCPS.  Ten other schools in MCPS have already installed cell towers on school grounds, and Whitman’s PTSA should approve the same.

Evidence of health effects is often speculative; cellphone towers “might” cause cancer, “could” pose a danger to our children and “may” be an unappreciated threat.  A few studies correlate radio wave exposure to a higher rate of health problems, but long-term studies will take years to prove or disprove the danger.

Meanwhile, an international conference of radio-communication health experts held at the beginning of February concluded that there is no evidence for health effects from exposure to radio waves.

Opponents compare cell phone towers to smoking, saying the full health risks of smoking were unknown 50 years ago.  While this analogy might put things into perspective, radio waves from cellphone towers are nothing like the toxic smoke inhaled from a pack of cigarettes each day.

Most cell sites emit less than one percent of the maximum exposure the Federal Communications Commission allows, and T-Mobile claims their sites emit less than a thousandth of a percent, making a tower less dangerous than cordless home phones and WiFi routers.

Even if FCC limits are too high, as many claim, cell towers are within safe emission levels recommended by experts. Ultimately, cellphones and two-way radios that are only inches from us are bigger concerns than a weak antenna 150 feet above our heads and hundreds of yards away.

Putting a cell tower on school grounds has many advantages.  T-Mobile users in the area would get a boost in coverage within a current dead zone.  In the future, other cell companies may add extensions to the cell tower to increase their coverage as well.

The athletic fields are the ideal site for the proposed tower.  The cell tower could be built into an existing light pole instead of towering over the neighborhood, keeping the tower as far away as possible from people’s homes and minimizing exposure to radio waves.

Finally, T-Mobile would pay $24,000 a year to MCPS, two-thirds of which would be split between Whitman and its cluster schools.  With Montgomery County’s $401 million budget shortfall, schools need extra revenue more than ever.

Radio waves surround our area and many others around the nation.  While it’s understandable to worry about the effects of these waves, a cellphone tower at Whitman isn’t going to be the straw that gives all of us cancer.  Instead, it would probably be one of the least worrisome sources of radio waves around.

The PSTA should approve the construction of a cell tower, and be rest assured that they are not condemning the next generation to death by it.

To read more about the proposed tower, click here.


6 Responses to “T-Mobile’s cellphone tower should be built on school grounds”

  1. Martin Weatherall on February 28th, 2010 10:53 pm

    What a lot of balony in Stewart Longsworth’s article!

    There are terrible health effects from cell phone antennas.

    To learn about those health effects, go to the Bio Initiative Report at

    Cell phone antennas should not be located near to schools because of the danger they pose to students.

  2. Ted Knox on March 1st, 2010 11:20 am
  3. R. Kerr on March 3rd, 2010 9:53 am

    I say, bring the tower. We’re soaked in transmissions at all times and chemicals since birth.

    In comparison to everything else our bodies are exposed to, I think this is of little significance.

  4. anonymous on March 7th, 2010 8:14 pm

    martin goes hard

  5. Bloody Sunday on March 9th, 2010 11:28 am

    Whether we like it or not, fanatics like Martin Weather are probably going to succeed in preventing the building of the tower, even though they are outnumbered. They care enough about the topic to show up to vote.

  6. Maureen L. Cropper on March 11th, 2010 8:32 am

    T-Mobile’s purpose in putting a cell tower on the school campus is NOT to improve service at the school where it claims the service is “best,” but to improve it for customers living ½ mile to the NW of the school. (Go to their website and put “7100 Whittier Blvd.” in the search bar on the coverage page—the map will show you what I mean.) And, the tower not just a “lighting pole.” It’s a pole 12 stories high, with 1789 sq. ft. of equipment around it (look at their site plan). What does the school get out of this? $8,000—or $4 per student—per year. The question is: why is the school so eager to do this?

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.

Email This Story

The Student News Site of Walt Whitman High School
T-Mobile’s cellphone tower should be built on school grounds